Menu
Versindaba
  • Nuwe Bundels
    • Digbundels (2024)
    • Digbundels (2023)
    • Digbundels (2022)
    • Digbundels (2021)
    • Digbundels (2020)
    • Digbundels (2019)
    • Digbundels (2018)
    • Digbundels (2017)
    • Digbundels (2016)
    • Digbundels (2015)
    • Digbundels (2014)
    • Digbundels (2013)
    • Digbundels (2012)
    • Digbundels (2011 & 2010)
  • Resensies
    • Resensies
    • Resensente
  • Gedigte
    • Gedigte (A-L)
    • Gedigte (M-Z)
    • Kompetisies
    • Vertalings
      • 100 Duitse bestes uit die 20ste eeu
  • Digters
    • Digters
    • Onderhoude
    • Stemgrepe
  • Skryfhulp
  • Borge
  • Oor Versindaba
    • Kontak
Versindaba
19 August 200919 August 2009

Is minder dalk meer?

Arundhathi Subramaniam
Arundhathi Subramaniam

Daniel Hugo se essay, “Die min maar suiwer note van die digter“, wat onlangs op die webblad geplaas is,  het my laat dink aan iets wat ek enkele dae gelede op die Indiese webruimte van Poetry International se webblad raakgelees het. Arundhathi Subramaniam, redakteur van die blad, het naamlik ’n aantal digters gevra oor hul beskouing jeens die inversie van woorde, naamlik stilte.

Sy het haar uitgangspunt soos volg gemotiveer aan hand van ‘n gedig deur Jerry Pinto: “Words are of course used by all of us, with increasing abundance it seems in an age of digital communication, and therein lies the challenge for poets – out of what the narrator of Jerry Pinto’s poem ‘The Trade’ describes as a thick sludgy militant flood pouring out of every profligate mouth, poets have to create art; something that will ‘echo’. The poet’s duty is to treat words as precious objects to be used with careful consideration, borne out of a recognition of and respect for silence.”

Dit wil my voorkom asof ons hier inderdaad te make het met die ou waarheid van “Minder is meer”, of hoe? Verdoof die oordaad aan kontekstualisering wat so geredelik ter wille van “toeganklike poësie” in eietydse poësie voorkom , nie dalk júís die stilte wat so ‘n integrale deel van “poëtiese impak” is nie? Want, eintlik is dít die ironie van die digkuns, soos Jerry Pinto dit in die vers waarna Subramaniam verwys, stel:

All words disrupt silence
But the only ones that echo
Are born in the silence they destroy.

(Uit: The trade deur Jerry Pinto)

Hieronder volg ’n ietwat uitgesponne vers deur Bharat Majhi. Die vertaling is gedoen deur Rabindra K. Swain. Ironies genoeg ondersteun dié vers nie noodwendig die punt wat Subramaniam hierbo probeer maak het nie, maar die slotreëls het darem ‘n mate van ‘n eggo.

Mooi bly.

LE

 

Some Words

Some words pissed on the head of history.
Some words took a pause
and looked forward to another day.
Some words took a bath in the river of quest
and wiping themselves dry
stood on the bank,
like neat and tidy love poetry.
They are now about to weep
in the poems.

Some words used to come
in dreams.
They are not to be seen
now that the dream has gone to sleep.
There was a time
when words leaned against
my shoulder.
They are not to be seen either.
They shoo away my hands
stretched towards them.

Some words sat closely on a bench
in a corner of the platform,
lost in conversation.
We can now understand their language.
If we now use them in our poems
there will be a sharp plunge
in the Sensex of the poetry market.

Some words are in the zoo,
some in boiling water.
some words are under the shade of teak trees,
some under the shade of a fig tree
waiting to see it flower.

Some words are by the pond
ready with a net
to catch the moon.
Some words are lost
in the vortices of the rains this year.

Some words will distribute
rice at two rupees per kilogramme,
as our Chief Minister has announced.
Some words are locked
In postures of coitus.
But many words keep mum
when it comes to feeding the hungry
or lifting the unfortunate to their feet,
making headlines in the national dailies.

I did not, in fact, need
these words.
They are, for me, too expensive.

© Bharat Majhi’s

Deel:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X

Like this:

Like Loading...

Lees meer

← Boekbekendstelling – “Halala Afrikaans”
Wanneer ‘n skrywer hom vererg … →

Lewer kommentaar Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Meeste gelees

  • Resensie: "Dawerende stiltes" (Caren Kearley)
  • Resensie: "Wilma Stockenström: Met my wysvingertop" (Ronel Foster, red.)
  • Marlies Taljard gesels met Yves T’Sjoen oor "De ontdekking van het eiland" (Deel 1)
  • Marlies Taljard gesels met Yves T’Sjoen oor "De ontdekking van het eiland" (Deel 3 - slot)
  • Joan Hambidge. Athol Harold Lannigan Fugard

Nuutste bydraes

  • Joan Hambidge. George Steiner, “On Difficulty”
  • Carina van der Walt. Madeleine en Marianne (uit “Paryse Dagboek”)
  • 100 Duitse Bestes: Durs Grünbein (1962-)
  • Marthé McLoud. Een aand op straat
  • Joan Hambidge. Die digkuns as weefwerk

Nuutste kommentaar

  1. Versindaba on 100 Duitse Bestes: Durs Grünbein (1962-)16 January 2026

    Van die kant van die Redaksie: Baie dankie Bernard Odendaal en Robert Schall dat Versindaba hierdie skitterende vertalings kon plaas.…

  2. Joan Hambidge on 100 Duitse Bestes: Durs Grünbein (1962-)15 January 2026

    Hierom dan dat George Steiner sy Poetry of thought aan hierdie manjifieke digter opgedra het. Ek (her)lees tans Steiner se…

  3. Joan Hambidge on 100 Duitse Bestes: Durs Grünbein (1962-)15 January 2026

    Dank. Die gedig as smoelneuker. Goed vertaal.

  4. Jacobus Swart on Joan Hambidge. Die digkuns as weefwerk14 January 2026

    Die digkuns is distillasie. Die taal is verhewig. Dit vereis dat die leser sy sokkies sal optrek. Want die digter…

  5. Bernard Odendaal on Joan Hambidge. Die digkuns as weefwerk13 January 2026

    “Lostorring” het my ewe diep getref, Joan.

Kategorieë

  • Artikels, essays, e.a.
  • Binneblik
  • Blogs
  • Digstring
  • Gedigte
  • Kompetisies
  • Nuus / Briewe
  • Nuwe Publikasie
  • Onderhoude
  • onderhoude
  • Resensies
  • Stemgrepe
  • Uncategorized
  • Vertalings
  • VWL 50 jaar later
  • Wisselkaarten
©2026 Versindaba | Ontwerp deur Frikkie van Biljon
%d